King of the Lake Superior
1845
One of the stories related to McKay’s take over is that schooners ALGONQUIN and Nepoleon formerly belonging to a Baltimore Company which failed, owed Captain John McKay quite a sum for his salary. A faster boat reached the Sault in advance of the one which was carrying the officers who were going to seize and sell the boats. Captain John McKay and another man ran the vessels over to the Canadian shore and beached them there and finally, when the officers arrived, he made a deal with the marshal to run the ALGONQUIN back into American waters, allow schooner to be seized and he then bought it in the amount of his claim.43 Schooners Uncle Tom and Swallow were two of ten new vessels5 hauled around the St. Mary Falls. They join the ALGONQUIN on Lake Superior.2
Sault Ste. Marie on June 12, 1945, the schooner ALGONQUIN arrived with about three tons of copper mineral from the Pittsburg Company Works, being the first sent down this season. Sent to Boston in half barrels with about 300 pounds copper ore in each. It was reported that the worth of the copper was $220 per ton when the ore was delivered to Boston.
Antoine Gordon opened a general store at La Pointe, Apostle Islands which he kept for 10 years. Meanwhile he bought the schooner ALGONQUIN and went into the lumber business, getting lumber at the mouth of the Bad River (south La Pointe on mainland) and transporting it to St. Croix, near the mouth of the Snake River, taking a stock of goods for trade with the Indians46 Later the vessel went to Fond du Lac, Minnesota.
The schooner then wintered over at Ste. Sault Marie.
1846
On June 3, 1846 survey party arrived at Sault de Ste. Marie and sailed on the ALGONQUIN that evening. The trip from Sault de Ste. Marie to Copper Harbor took about three days.
1847
Fleet on Lake Superior increased rapidly due to “copper rush.” Steamboats Julia Palmer 280 tons, propeller Independence 280 tons, Schooner Napoleon 180 tons, ALGONQUIN, Merchant and Swallow each 70 tons, Schooners Uncle Tom, Chippewa, Fur Trader and Siskawit each about 40 tons.
During the year, the company which owned the ALGONQUIN defaulted on payments. At lest the ALGONQUIN and Napoleon according to the former Captain John McKay.

Captain Barton Atkins met Mr. Cutting, owner of a mine in Lake Superior region, and agreed to go up to his mine and keep the time of the men working there and also keep an account of the provisions which were used by the miners. He remained at the mine there until June 6, 1847 when he went down to the mouth of Eagle River (south of Copper Harbor), where the schooner ALGONQUIN, was anchored. The schooner was being commanded by Captain John Halloran.
John McKay was owner in 1848. John’s son, George McKay told that his father was captain of crew that had four halfbreeds, man and himself at an age of 12 years old. the vessel befoned to a Baltimore company which failed. His father took over the ship for lost wages and sailed to Canada. Deal was made and McKay received ALGONQUIN for wages not paided and second ship was given to the reprocessors who then sold it for debts that were owed to the company. (Note: It is unclear if the incident occured in 1847 or 1848.)
1848
The schooner changed ownership on July 27, 1848 in Sault Ste Marie District to Sheldon McKnight of Sault Ste Marie and John Halloran took over as captain.
1849
The ALGONQUIN’S captains during the year were Lewis Bancroft and John McKay.
1851
The schooner was at Copper Harbor with Captain Smith at the helm on July 23, 1851.
The schooner ALGONQUIN took up to Ontonagon 2000 kegs of powder.

![]() Light House at Eagle Harbor 1853 Harper's New Monthly Magazine |
Captain Wilson and Monticello departed Ontonagon on the afternoon of September 22, 1851 on her return from Fond du Lac. While departing from harbor, a heavy floating log struck a wheel which loosened the cargo near the shaft. Leak developed which was thought to be small. Captain believed the ship could make the trip of sixty miles north to Eagle River. Ship started sinking and crew and passenger could not keep up with the incoming water. The Captain then decided to send a party from the ship to Eagle River by land. The party had a extremely difficult time in the wilderness. It took party several very difficult days to reach a settlement at Eagle River. |
On Tuesday, September 30th, Capt McKay who commanded the schooner ALOGNQUIN proceeded to the wreck of Monticello and brought off the captain, crew and remaining passengers along with all its valuable property.
Captain Wilson and Monticello departed Ontonagon on the afternoon of September 22, 1851 on her return from Fond du Lac. While departing from harbor, a heavy floating log struck a wheel which loosened the cargo near the shaft. Leak developed which was thought to be small. Captain believed the ship could make the trip of sixty miles north to Eagle River. Ship started sinking and crew and passenger could not keep up with the incoming water. The Captain then decided to send a party from the ship to Eagle River by land. The party had a extremely difficult time in the wilderness. It took party several very difficult days to reach a settlement at Eagle River. On Tuesday, September 30th, Capt McKay who commanded the schooner ALOGNQUIN proceeded to the wreck of Monticello and brought off the captain, crew and remaining passengers along with all its valuable property.
The schooner ALGONQUIN, Captain John McKay arrived at Copper Harbor on the October 6th inst. with forty49 of the shipwrecked passengers and crew of the MONTICELLO, and all the articles saved from the wreck.
Soon after leaving Copper Harbor after October 7th, a heavy gale came in from the W.N.W., which made a log house shake that we happened to be in that place. Captain McKay ran in under Point Keweenaw for lee, but the wind was too much for ALGONQUIN anchors and Captain McKay was obliged to beat about under the coast for twelve hours, during which time he never left the helm of the schooner. The passengers spoke of the conduct of the captain and of his vessel in the highest terms.
©2008 All rights reserved. This page and other pages in the book are property of the
Algonquin Historic Commission and its creator Donald V. Purn. Pages may be copied
for eductional uses only. Pages or any part can be reproduced for profit enterprizes.
Hosted by INTERNATIONAL TECHNOLOGY SALES
www.itsavaya.com
847-639-0775
